Fatigue Pitting Failure Analysis of Tooth Surface of Spiral Bevel Gear for EMU Train
LI Qiuze1,2, WANG Wenjing1, CHEN Liang2, SUN Shouguang1
1. School of Mechanical, Electric and Control Engineering, Beijing Jiaotong University, Beijing 100044, China;
2. CRRC Changchun Railway Vehicle Co. Ltd., Changchun 130062, China
In order to overcome the fatigue pitting failure of tooth surface of spiral bevel gears for electric multiple unit (EMU) trains, the pitting failure locations were firstly summarized and both macro-and micro-morphologies of the pitting fracture surfaces were investigated. Then, based on the track test of EMU trains in practical service, the load spectrum of gear was compiled thoroughly, and the contact stress of gear was calculated according to the ISO 10300-2-2001. In addition, a series of bench loading tests under different operational conditions were conducted to obtain the variety law of the contact area. At the condition of the equivalent loading torque, the lengths of Herz contact lines and the diameters of pitch circles were determined in the contact area of cylindrical gear and that in the normal direction at the tooth width center, and the contact stress and contract area of gears were also analyzed. The results show that the concave contact area at the end of small gear teeth of the driven spiral bevel is the normal contact area under variable loading conditions, while the contact area would be off the tooth width center line under the equivalent torque loading condition. When the length of contact line and the diameter of pitch circle are less than those obtained from theoretical analysis, the actual contact stress (972.23 MPa) will be larger than the theoretical contact stress (777.26 MPa). As a result, in order to avoid the fatigue pitting failure, it is suggested adjusting the contact area of gear concave to the center of tooth width under the equivalent torque loading condition.
��Դ,Ԭ�ܺ�. ���ռ������������ֶ�̬���Ϸ����[J]. ��е����,2007,31(5):43-44. LI Yuan, YUAN Jiehong. A simulating analysis model for spiral bevel gear dynamic mesh-ing in aerostat reducer[J]. Journal of Mechanical Transmission, 2007, 31(5):43-44.
[2]
���ڵ�,��Ч��,�ζ���. ���DZ�Ե�Ӵ��Ļ������ֳ��ؽӴ�����[J]. ��е����ѧ��,2002,38(9):69-72. FANG Zongde, DENG Xiaozhong, REN Dongfeng. Loaded tooh contact analysia of spring bevel gears considering edge contact[J]. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2002, 38(9):69-72
[3]
���ڵ�,����,����ΰ,��. ���ٻ������ֶ�̬���������Ż�[J]. ����ѧ��,2001,22(1):69-72. FANG Zongde, YANG Hongbin, ZHOUYanwei, et al. Optimization of dynamic meshing behavior of high speed spiral bevel gears[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica, 2001, 22(1):69-72.
[4]
��Ч��,���ڵ�,�Ž���,��. �������ֵĸ��غ϶����[J]. �й���е����,2002,13(9):791-795. DENG Xiaozhong, FANG Zongde, ZHANG jinliang, et al. Design of spiral bevel gears with high contact ratio[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 2002, 13(9):791-795.
[5]
��Ч��,���ڵ�,����,��. ���غ϶Ȼ������ֵ�ǿ�ȷ���[J]. ���ն���ѧ��,2002,17(3):367-372. DENG Xiaozhong, FANG Zongde, YANG Hongbin, et al. Strength analysis of spiral bevel gears with high contact ratio[J]. Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica, 2002, 17(3):367-372.
[6]
�����,���Զ�. ����������̬���Ϸ������[J]. ��е����ʦ,2008(1):143-145. ZHONG Cenhong, ZHANG Yidu. A quasi-static meshing simulating analysis for spiral bevel gear[J].Mechanical Enginner, 2008(1):143-145.
[7]
�Ž���,���ڵ�,��ѩ÷,��. �������ֳ���Ӵ�Ӧ������[J]. ��е��ѧ�뼼��,2007,26(10):1268-1272. ZHANG Jinliang, FANG Zongde, CAO Xuemei, et al. Analysis of a spiral bevel gear's tooth contact stress[J]. Mechanical Science and Technology for Aerospace Engineering, 2007, 26(10):1268-1272.
[8]
����ӱ,���ڵ�,��Ч��,��. ������������Ԫ��ģ��Ӵ�����[J]. ���������̴�ѧѧ��,2015,36(6):826-830. HOU Xiangying, FANG Zongde, DENG Xiaozhong, et al. Contact analysis of spiral bevel gears based on finite element model[J]. Journal of Harbin Engineering University, 2015, 36(6):826-830.
[9]
�ս�չ,���ڵ�,����ΰ. �����������ֻ��������Ϸ������������[J]. ������ҵ��ѧѧ��,2012,30(4):565-569. SU Jinzhan, FANG Zongde, CAI Xiangwe. A useful computerized meshing analysis of numerical tooth surfaces for spiral bevel gears[J]. Journal of Northwestern Polytechnical University, 2012, 30(4):565-569.
[10]
Ф��ǿ,����. ����˫ѹ������������ƵĻ������ֽӴ�Ӧ������������[J]. ��е����ѧ��,2015,38(9):69-72. XIAO Wangqiang, LI Wei. Analysis andexperiment of contact stress for spiral bevel gear based on lightweight design of double pressure angles[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2015, 38(9):69-72.
[11]
����,�ؾ���,�γ�Ȼ,��. �������ִ�����������������Ż�[J]. ������Ϣ�Ƽ���ѧѧ��,2014, 29(6):37-40. HE Qu, HE Jingliang, HE Changren, et al. Simulation analysis of spiral bevel gear transmission and optimization by tooth profile modification[J]. Journal of Beijing Information Science and Technology, 2014, 29(6):37-40.
[12]
ISO. ISO6336-6-2006 Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears-part 5:trength and quality of materials[S]. Second Edition.:The International Organization for Standardization, 2003.
[13]
ISO. ISO10300-2-2001 Calculation of load capacity of bevel gears-part 2:calculation of surface durability (pitting)[S].:The International Organization for Standardization, 2001.
[14]
ISO. ISO6336-6-2006Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears-part 6:calculation of service life under variable load[S]. Second Edition.:The International Organization for Standardization, 2003.